Since there isn’t and I’m writing this article on Halloween, what else is there for me to do but talk about the customs of All Soul’s Day (November 2nd)?
What? Not All Saints Day? Of course not. That day is for all the souls that don’t need Purgatory to cleanse them of their foibles and send them on to Heaven. We’re going to Purgatory to save the rest of us sinners for this one.
The official name of this celebration in the Roman Catholic Church liturgy is "The Commemoration of All the Faithful Departed”. The idea is that there are faithful souls stuck in Purgatory because they either died without being cleansed of their venial sins or are being held back due to unrepented mortal sins. It is the obligation of those still on Earth to help these poor souls on their way through prayer. The setting aside a special day for the departed souls was established in 998 AD by Odilo of Cluny, then spread across Europe although it wasn’t adopted by Rome until the Fourteenth Century. The practice included not only prayers but placing lists of names to be remembered on or near the altar during Mass.
Like many Church traditions this one got tangled up with older cultural practice, such as Lemuralia or Lemuria, a Roman feast in May to exorcise the malevolent and fearful ghosts of the dead with offering of beans.
During Lemuria the Vestals would prepare sacred mola salsa, a salted flour cake, from the first ears of wheat of the season. This feast was eventually Christianized into All Saints Day, but as you’ll see below it spilled over—or at least the cake did—onto All Souls Day.
Enter “Souling”. This tradition is much like Wassailing, and no doubt the fount from which Trick or Treating sprang, although the pulling pranks part of Halloween has its own tradition in Scotland. During the Middle Ages children and beggars went door-to-door “Souling” on All Souls Day not All Hallow’s Eve (Halloween) singing a Souling song:
“Soul, Soul, a soul cake!
I pray thee, good missus, a soul cake!
One for Peter, two for Paul,
three for Him what made us all!
Soul, soul for a souling cake
I pray you, missis, for a souling cake
Apple or pear, plum or cherry
Anything to make us merry.”
And what’s a Soul Cake? We over here in the US will know it as a sugar cookie, although being British it’s not a really sweet sugar cookie.
It’s flat, round and marked with a cross much like the back of a Medieval coin. For those interested in baking one here’s the recipe: (makes 14 large cookies)
1 ½ cup plain flour (sifted)
¾ cup sugar
½ tsp ground cinnamon
½ tsp ground mixed spice
½ tsp ground nutmeg
¾ cup butter (softened & diced)
1 egg (beaten)
2 tsp vinegar
Currants or raisins, if desired
Preheat oven to 400 degrees. Butter a cookie sheet. Sift together the dry indredients then using a pastry blender cut in butter until it looks like fine breadcrumbs. Mix in the beaten egg and the vinegar with a wooden spoon until the dough is firm. Form into a ball, wrap in plastic and place in the fridge for 20 minutes. When chilled, place on a floured board or other flat surface and roll out to about ¼ inch thick.
Using a large round pastry cutter (a sharp-edged small bowl will work as a template) cut into rounds. Place on the greased cookie sheet and with the dull edge of a table knife press the cross shape into the top of the cookie. Bake for 15 to 20 minutes until golden brown. Serve warm or cold.
Although the tradition of eating this cake is supposedly related to praying, in the sense that the consumption of one was akin to a prayer in church, it makes me think of sin eating. Sin eating was a traditional ritual practiced throughout England, Scotland and Wales, persisting until the late 19th or early 20th century in areas of Wales and the Welsh Marches (Shropshire and Herefordshire). It also has a tradition here in Appalachia in the same areas where where expressions retain the flavor of Elizabethan/Jacobean English. This ritual, usually attached to the graveside or deathbed, also includes the eating of some sort of food after said food has been placed upon the breast of the dying person to absorb their departing soul/sin. By consuming the food the person eating it takes the sin into himself. The only difference with Souling is that the person for whom the cake is being consumed is already dead and in Purgatory.
Oh, and by the way there was a precursor to a carved pumpkin in the Middle Ages. (We all know that hard squash like pumpkins, along with corn, potatoes and tomatoes, are a New World—American—food, right?) You’ll never guess. Okay, I’ll give: turnips! Turnips can actually get quite big, although never the size of a proper Halloween pumpkin. At this larger size turnips lose their sweetness and are probably only good for carving. Or making great veggie stock for soups, which is what I do with them.
Happy Turnip Day!
Denise Domning's first medieval romance, Winter's Heat, received the Romantic Times award for Best First Historical Novel in 1994. Spring's Fury, Autumn's Flame, A Love for All Seasons were respectively nominated by Romantic Times for Best Medieval Novel in 1995, 1996 and 1997. Her first Elizabethan novel, Lady in Waiting, was recommended by Publisher's Weekly as well written and researched, with an accurate portrayal of Elizabeth I. Denise has co-authored an autobiography with Monica Sarli about her life entitled Men-ipulation. Denise's website is www.DeniseDomning.com.
Many of Denise's books are also available on Kindle. Click on the titles above.

